top of page

Review: Reforged by Seth Haddon

  • Writer: Leo
    Leo
  • Mar 20
  • 2 min read

Spoiler-free, as always. (Everything I say that may sound like a spoiler is in the book's marketing)


Genres: Fantasy/romance



The romance is between the king and his bodyguard/knight (called a paladin) who have romantic history from before the paladin started his training and the king was a prince. They fell out of touch, and you can really feel that longing and wistfulness in the paladin's inner thoughts


One of the smaller reasons I have a hard time reading romances is if I don't like the love interest. I believed the MC's love for him, and the reasons the LI was off-putting were justified by the narrative. He still got on my nerves at .


Romance build-up was nicely intertwined with the progress of the narrative, which I appreciated. There were two sex scenes, which I thought were tastefully reserved/limited in number, and well-earned by the narrative. It didn't feel gratuitous or forced at all, more like a natural extension of the author showing the bond between the characters


The plot twist at the end was not something I saw coming because I thought the plot twist was going to be something much worse and grotesque. (I thought there was going to be a flesh golem involved)


Stakes and scope were big enough to feel like I was part of something vast and amazing, but focused enough to feel like the characters are part of something vast and amazing, with their limited perspectives



Rating: 8/10

LMSS: 7.5 - Rules weren't defined explicitly, but you could pick out approximately what seemed possible by the time the final battles happened. Everything magical the characters were able to do felt earned as they honed their skills over the course of the novel

Recent Posts

See All
Review: The Raven Tower by Anne Leckie

Fucking amazing fantasy storytelling. Made me inspired to emulate parts of her style in my own writing. Trans main character for the win. Incredible world building that makes the world feel lived in b

 
 
Review: Reclaimed by Seth Haddon

*It is not necessary to read Reforged, Reborn, and Reclaimed in order (that order), but there are references to other locations and names that can only been understood after reading the rest of the tr

 
 
Leo's Magic System Scale

In most of my book reviews, I give the book two ratings. A general 1-10 rating, and what I'm calling the "Leo's Magic System Scale" (LMSS for short (is that stupid? eh, who cares)) Unlike a typical 1-

 
 

Hi there! This website is still under construction. An email list thingy will go here someday. Until then, cheers!

© 2026 by Leo R. Skoble
 

Homepage artwork by K. M. Morris


See a typo? Accessibility issues? Let me know by emailing Leo@Leorskoble.com!

  • Instagram
bottom of page